SHAH ALAM – Hate against the Rohingya community on social media may not always be organic, with some hostility allegedly being manufactured or amplified to turn refugees into a political “bogeyman”, said Rohingya activist Yasmin Ullah.
The Rohingya Maiyafuinor Collaborative Network executive director said political actors could exploit fears surrounding refugees by portraying them as a threat and positioning themselves as protectors of the local population.
Speaking on a local podcast titled 'Why Are the Rohingya Still in Malaysia?', she said she had observed similar dynamics during elections in Indonesia, where the Rohingya were allegedly used as an “unknown group” that could be blamed for wider concerns.
“That is my theory, and it’s playing out again here. It was playing out in the Indonesian election and a lot of political parties were using the Rohingya as a bogeyman, portraying them as an unfamiliar or unknown group,” she said.
Yasmin said misinformation targeting the Rohingya could also be difficult for local communities to challenge because of language barriers.
She cited claims circulating online that Rohingya were “not real Muslims” because they could not recite the shahada as an example of misinformation directed at the community.
Yasmin also referred to monitoring by Indonesian digital rights organisation Safenet, saying it had examined the traffic surrounding some hate-speech posts.
“Safenet, another human rights organisation that does a lot of digital literacy and monitoring of human rights violations online, was actually talking about how the traffic of these posts was not quite human, but most of this content was being pushed out at 2 or 3am in the morning,” she said.
She said the findings raised questions about whether some of the content could have been coordinated, although she stressed that those behind it were not known.
The discussion also examined a possible link between developments involving the Rohingya at international courts and periods when the issue appeared to receive renewed attention on Malaysian social media.
In 2019, the Rohingya crisis became the subject of two separate international legal proceedings.
At the International Criminal Court (ICC), Pre-Trial Chamber III authorised the Prosecutor on Nov 14, 2019 to commence an investigation into the situation in Bangladesh and Myanmar.
The investigation covers crimes within the Court’s jurisdiction, including alleged crimes against humanity such as deportation and persecution of the Rohingya, where at least part of the alleged conduct occurred on the territory of Bangladesh, an ICC member state.
Separately, The Gambia filed proceedings against Myanmar at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) under the Genocide Convention, alleging that Myanmar had breached its obligations under the convention in relation to the Rohingya.
In January 2020, the ICJ ordered provisional measures requiring Myanmar to take measures to prevent acts falling within the scope of the Genocide Convention against the Rohingya and to preserve evidence related to the allegations.
In July 2022, the Court rejected Myanmar’s preliminary objections and found that it had jurisdiction to hear the case and that The Gambia’s application was admissible.
During the discussion, the host pointed to what he described as a pattern in which discussion of the Rohingya appeared to intensify on Malaysian social media months after developments in the international proceedings.
Yasmin said she did not believe the hostility was necessarily coincidental.
She argued that political actors could “securitise” the Rohingya issue by presenting the community as a threat requiring stronger action, particularly around elections or major political developments.
“When it comes to international court cases or general elections, politicians tend to securitise the Rohingya issue because they want to be seen as the hero,” she said.
Yasmin said such narratives could create a need for a group to be portrayed as a threat, allowing politicians to position themselves as protectors.
She compared the pattern with political rhetoric targeting migrants elsewhere, including in the United States, while stressing that the consequences could be particularly serious when directed at already marginalised communities.
“It’s also playing out here, perhaps in a more sinister way, because it is targeting some of the most marginalised groups in society, not just the Rohingya,” she said.
Yasmin added that the possible connection between developments in international court proceedings and spikes in online discussion was something she had not previously considered in depth.
The discussion also took place against the backdrop of heightened debate over migrants and refugees in Malaysia during the Covid-19 pandemic.
In 2020, Malaysian authorities conducted raids and detained undocumented migrants as part of enforcement operations during the pandemic.
Al Jazeera’s 101 East documentary, Locked Up in Malaysia’s Lockdown, aired on July 3, 2020 and examined the treatment of undocumented migrant workers during the lockdown.
The documentary featured Bangladeshi migrant worker Mohamed Rayhan Kabir, who criticised the treatment of undocumented migrants.
Kabir was arrested on July 24, 2020, while the Immigration Department later announced that his work permit had been revoked and that he would be deported and blacklisted from returning to Malaysia.
He was deported to Bangladesh on Aug 21, according to Human Rights Watch, which described his arrest as retaliation for his criticism of the government’s treatment of migrant workers. Malaysian authorities rejected allegations that the documentary accurately represented the situation and investigated its production.
The episode became part of a wider debate over how migrants and refugees were discussed during the pandemic, with human rights organisations criticising aspects of the government’s response while authorities defended their actions.
For Yasmin, the larger concern is what happens when repeated claims about refugees transform them from a humanitarian issue into a perceived security threat.
She argued that once a community is framed as the “other”, fear can become easier to mobilise, particularly during elections or periods of political uncertainty.
The challenge, she suggested, is therefore not only to address individual pieces of misinformation but also to understand who is producing, amplifying and potentially benefiting from narratives surrounding refugees.