KLSCAH land premium reduction draws criticism from academic

Iklan
Kuala Lumpur and Selangor Chinese Assembly Hall. Inset: Emeritus Professor Datuk Dr Teo Kok Seong. -Photo: National Heritage Department.

Emeritus professor questions decision to slash estimated RM4.67 million premium to RM1,000, also raises concerns over use of Malay at announcement ceremony

 

SHAH ALAM – The reduction of the Kuala Lumpur and Selangor Chinese Assembly Hall's (KLSCAH) land premium from an estimated RM4.67 million to RM1,000 has drawn criticism from Emeritus Professor Datuk Dr Teo Kok Seong, who described the decision as shocking and unreasonable.

Iklan
Iklan

He said the decision was surprising not only because it came shortly after a change in leadership of the portfolio, which had previously been controversial, but also because of the significant reduction.

He added that such a reduction had not been made before the leadership change.

Iklan

According to Teo, reducing the land premium from millions of ringgit to just RM1,000 would be difficult for many to accept, given the scale of the concession.

"The RM4.67 million premium set before the reduction must have been based on concrete grounds and reasons.

Iklan

"In other words, there must have been valid justification for the premium, even after KLSCAH was gazetted as a heritage site in 2007," he said in a statement on Monday.

On November 14, the government approved a 99-year lease renewal for the KLSCAH land, with the premium set at RM1,000, down from the previous estimated amount of RM4.67 million.

Iklan

Minister in the Prime Minister's Department (Federal Territories) Hannah Yeoh reportedly announced the decision at KLSCAH's 103rd anniversary dinner.

According to Bernama, the Federal Territories Land Committee approved the surrender and re-alienation of the land for institutional use on September 14.

The official approval letter dated October 1 set the land premium at RM1,000, while the total amount payable was RM5,011, including the first year's land rent and administrative charges.

The annual land rent was set at RM3,151.

The decision followed Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's commitment to give special consideration to efforts to preserve the historic building after visiting the hall during Chinese New Year celebrations on February 17.

Commenting further, Teo, who is also a senior fellow at the National Professors Council, said setting the land premium at just RM1,000 amounted to rejecting, disrespecting and betraying the portfolio, which had existed since 1979, particularly its previous leaders.

He said the explanation that land premiums had also been reduced for several other heritage sites in Kuala Lumpur was an attempt to deflect criticism over what he described as an excessive and unreasonable reduction for KLSCAH.

Teo said the decision was insensitive and could trigger controversy and affect the country's social harmony.

Apart from questioning the reduction, he also raised concerns over the language used during the official announcement ceremony.

"The announcement ceremony was undoubtedly an official function under the portfolio, and indeed an official national event, yet it appeared to sideline the country's national identity and the people's cultural identity," he said.

He said the event should have been conducted in the national language, but Malay was not given priority.

"Such incidents continue to happen despite repeated criticism, and are even being completely disregarded by government agencies themselves," he said.

Teo said the situation should not be allowed to continue, as Malay, which serves as both the national and official language, was being disregarded.