GE16: Can Anwar afford to wait?

Iklan
BN's return to power with 21 of the 28 seats, alongside three seats won by PN allies PAS and Parti Wawasan Negara, gave the Muafakat Melaka arrangement a 24-seat majority in Saturday's state election. The result highlighted how electoral cooperation between BN and PN could consolidate support and avoid vote-splitting. -Bernama FILE PIX

The economy offers little urgency for an early election, but BN-PN cooperation, a succession of state polls and shifting political alliances are putting the unity government's future under scrutiny

THE emphatic victory by the Barisan Nasional-Perikatan Nasional (BN-PN) alliance in the Melaka state election has brought the question of an early 16th General Election (GE16) into sharper focus.

On Saturday, BN's return to power with 21 of the 28 seats, alongside PN's three seats through its allies PAS and Parti Wawasan Negara, gave the Muafakat Melaka arrangement a commanding 24-seat majority. More significantly, the result demonstrated what electoral cooperation between BN and PN could achieve when they avoid splitting votes and concentrate support in a contest.

Iklan
Iklan

The outcome follows BN's successes in Johor and Negeri Sembilan, reinforcing the party's position and raising questions about how far its cooperation with PN could extend beyond state-level politics.

For Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, the implications go beyond Melaka. 

Iklan

BN remains a partner in the unity government in Putrajaya, but its growing electoral cooperation with PN presents a difficult political contradiction. How long can parties remain government partners while preparing to face each other, or cooperate against Pakatan Harapan (PH), at the next general election?

On the economic front, there is little compelling reason for Anwar to call an early election. The government can argue that it needs time to implement its policies, strengthen the recovery and demonstrate results from its reform agenda.

Iklan

Cost-of-living pressures remain a concern for households, and economic improvements have yet to translate into a sufficiently convincing sense of relief for many Malaysians. An early election could therefore expose the government to questions about whether it has delivered enough since taking office.

Waiting would give Anwar more time to consolidate his administration's record. It would also allow PH to work on rebuilding support among Malay voters without risking further erosion of its non-Malay support base.

Iklan

But time is not necessarily on the government's side politically.

The sequence of state elections also matters when assessing the timing of GE16. 

Sarawak is due to hold its state election on Dec 12, 2026, while Perlis, Perak and Pahang, whose assemblies were elected alongside GE15 in November 2022, are on a similar electoral cycle to Parliament. Their elections could therefore be held alongside GE16, depending on when the respective assemblies are dissolved.

The position is different in Kedah, Kelantan, Terengganu, Selangor and Penang. These five states last went to the polls in August 2023, and their assembly terms run until 2028. Unless they are dissolved early, their next state elections are expected to take place after GE16.

Negeri Sembilan, which also held its election in 2023, has since returned to the polls in August 2026 following an early dissolution. Johor and Melaka have also held their state elections in 2026.

This means Anwar is not facing a single, nationwide electoral deadline. There is room to coordinate GE16 with some state elections, particularly in Perlis, Perak and Pahang, but the constitutional timetable does not require all state governments to go to the polls at the same time.

Parliament's five-year term, which began with its first sitting on Dec 19, 2022, runs until Dec 19, 2027. If it is not dissolved earlier, Parliament will automatically dissolve, with a general election required within 60 days.

Anwar therefore has constitutional room to wait. The question is whether he has the political room to do so.

The Melaka result gives BN and PN an incentive to maintain their cooperation. For BN, working with PN offers a route to consolidate Malay support and reduce the risk of splitting votes in constituencies where both parties compete for a similar electorate.

For PAS and PN, cooperation with BN could broaden their electoral reach and improve their prospects in seats where a divided opposition would otherwise benefit PH.

But the arrangement is not without complications. Seat allocation, leadership ambitions and the balance of power between PAS and Bersatu could become contentious as GE16 approaches. A state-level understanding does not automatically translate into a nationwide agreement.

BN also has to weigh the advantages of remaining in the unity government against the political benefits of aligning more closely with PN. Its position in Putrajaya gives it access to government machinery, influence and Cabinet representation. Yet continued cooperation with PN could make its role in the unity government increasingly difficult to defend.

For PH, this is an uncomfortable position. BN's 30 parliamentary seats are important to the government's survival. Losing BN would weaken the coalition's parliamentary position and potentially create an opening for its opponents.

It faces a difficult choice. It can continue working with BN in Putrajaya and hope that the partnership holds until GE16. But the longer BN develops its electoral relationship with PN, the harder it becomes for PH to explain why a government partner is cooperating with political rivals who may seek to replace it.

An early election could force the issue before BN-PN cooperation becomes more firmly established. But it would also mean PH going to the polls while still trying to regain Malay support and defend its standing among non-Malay voters.

There is also the possibility of PH looking beyond BN and exploring a different political arrangement with Bersatu to strengthen its Malay support.

However, that would be a difficult proposition. Bersatu's role in the Sheraton Move in 2020, which led to the collapse of the PH government after the party withdrew from the coalition, remains a major obstacle to rebuilding trust. For DAP and many PH supporters, the political memory of that episode cannot simply be set aside.

Even if such an arrangement were considered, it is far from certain that Bersatu could deliver the Malay votes PH needs.

Thus, the  political calculations become more complicated.

For Anwar, the challenge is not simply deciding when to dissolve Parliament. It is managing a government whose component parties may already be preparing for very different political futures.

The economy may not yet demand an early election, but politics could. Anwar can decide when to dissolve Parliament. What he cannot decide is how long his partners will remain comfortable with their current political arrangements.

GE16 may still be more than a year away, but the real contest over who will face whom – and with whom – has already begun.