Hannah defends RM1,000 land premium for Chinese Assembly Hall

Iklan
Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Federal Territories) Hannah Yeoh.

She says the reduced rate takes into account KLSCAH's decision to change its land status to institutional use and give up commercial development potential

 

SHAH ALAM – Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Federal Territories) Hannah Yeoh has defended the government’s decision to impose a RM1,000 land premium on the Kuala Lumpur and Selangor Chinese Assembly Hall (KLSCAH), following criticism from several quarters, including Umno and Pas leaders.

Iklan
Iklan

She said the rate took into account KLSCAH’s agreement to change the land status to institutional use, which meant giving up the potential for commercial development such as condominiums and shopping malls.

“The land premium rate must take into account the conditions and potential use of the land, rather than being based solely on its commercial development value.

Iklan

“They say we have given away government revenue and that we should have collected RM4 million. Why allow the Chinese to avoid paying taxes? Hannah Yeoh and DAP are looking after their own community. That is the narrative being pushed,” she said in a statement on Tuesday.

On Monday, Sinar reported that the RM1,000 land premium imposed on KLSCAH had drawn criticism from several politicians and activists, who questioned the justification for reducing the amount from its initial estimated value of RM4.67 million.

Iklan

Among the concerns raised were whether similar reductions would be extended to other institutions and whether the government was giving preferential treatment to certain organisations.

Hannah said the 103-year-old KLSCAH building was also facing financial difficulties, with an annual operating deficit of about RM400,000 due to rising maintenance costs, the building's ageing condition and the need to upgrade its safety features and technical facilities.

Iklan

She also clarified the differences between land premiums, quit rent, assessment tax, income tax and People's Housing Project (PPR) rent, which she said had been confused in the controversy.

“Land premiums are paid to the government based on the conditions and potential use of the land, while quit rent is paid to the land office.

“Assessment tax is paid to Kuala Lumpur City Hall (DBKL) for local authority services, including waste collection, while income tax is paid to the Inland Revenue Board (LHDN) and PPR rent is paid to the property owner.

“It's exhausting having to teach Umno and Pas leaders the differences between the various types of taxes. Their top leaders and family members still owe billions in income tax,” she said.

Hannah also questioned the track record of previous administrations in Kuala Lumpur, claiming that Umno had previously sold public fields and flood retention ponds, while Pas had defended the sale of public recreational fields when it governed under Perikatan Nasional (PN).

“What solutions did they offer for flooding in Kuala Lumpur? Sandbags. The leaders and activists exploiting race and religion in Kuala Lumpur are much the same – they play up the issue simply because I am a Chinese minister and a DAP minister. That's all,” she said.

She also rejected claims that the government was focusing only on KLSCAH, saying DBKL had introduced initiatives to assist traders in the capital regardless of race or religion.

“DBKL is offering a 50 per cent rental discount to 10,000 traders in Kuala Lumpur, not for one year but for two years.

“Our Ramadan bazaar stall rental rates are also among the lowest in Malaysia, at RM400 per lot for the entire Ramadan period. In Kuala Lumpur, we look after everyone, regardless of race or religion,” she added.

Addressing criticism over KLSCAH’s decision to change the land status to institutional use, Hannah said preserving heritage buildings should be seen as an effort to safeguard Kuala Lumpur’s history and identity.

“How can greedy and corrupt leaders understand the value of heritage buildings to Kuala Lumpur? If they truly understood, they would have upgraded and maintained the Sultan Abdul Samad Building and Carcosa Seri Negara properly a long time ago.

“Who carried out the restoration? Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim. At the time, they also questioned why RM600 million was spent on it,” she added.