SHAH ALAM - MCA and DAP may gain more Chinese voter support if they work together, but the move would not necessarily help them secure enough votes to form a government.
Political analyst Dr Syaza Shukri said even if both parties managed to secure 90 per cent of Chinese votes, it would only make up about 18 per cent of the total votes.
"That's not enough for anything. They still need to work with other parties . Who or what is this other party?" she said.
She said bringing MCA and DAP together could also make ethnic politics even more pronounced, with Umno and Pas on one side and MCA and DAP on the other.
While some might argue that Malaysian politics was already divided along racial lines, Syaza said the current arrangement still allowed parties to work across ethnic groups.
She said MCA's cooperation with Umno and DAP's position in Pakatan Harapan (PH) left more room for political alliances that went beyond ethnicity.
Syaza also questioned whether MCA and DAP could put aside their differences, particularly when it came to ideology and leadership.
She said the proposed cooperation could face a similar uncertainty as the relationship between Umno and Pas, which had also struggled to maintain their political partnership.
"Like people are saying Umno-Pas may or may not survive long term, I think the same fate might fall for MCA-DAP cooperation," she said.
Her comments came after former MCA president Tan Sri Dr Chua Soi Lek questioned why MCA and DAP continued to fight when neither party could form a government on its own.
In an interview with Lindsay Tee on Instagram, Chua described the rivalry as a zero-sum game, where one party's gain came at the expense of the other.
"The contest between DAP and MCA is a zero-sum game. Nobody wins, nobody loses. You win, I lose. I win, you lose," he said.
He added that both parties still needed support from other political parties to form a government and cited Umno and Pas as an example of former rivals who had managed to work together.