To do or not to do: Netizens divided over school guidelines for Palestine Solidarity Week

SHAH ALAM – A recent infographic by Education Minister Fadhlina Sidek on guidelines for Palestine Solidarity Week in schools has stirred debate online.

The guidelines spell out specific "dos" and "don'ts."

Don'ts:

1. Avoid Extremist Rhetoric: The top "don't" cautions against extremist language.
2. Don't Blame Individuals or Religions: Schools are advised not to generalise or blame particular groups.
3. Stick to Facts: Guidelines stress the importance of factual information.
4. Steer Clear of Partisan Politics: Schools should not take sides or provide platforms for political entities.
5. Avoid Single Perspective: Calls for a balanced portrayal of the situation.
6. Skip Controversial Symbols: Flags, slogans, or images that may offend should be avoided.

Dos:

1. Highlight Humanitarian Dimension: Humanitarian efforts and peace should be prioritised.
2. Promote Understanding: Schools are encouraged to hold educational events like lectures and documentary screenings.
3. Encourage Open Dialogue: Facilitate Q&A sessions and forums.
4. Collaborate with NGOs: Involve humanitarian organisations in programs.
5. Charity Campaign: Collect donations for humanitarian aid.
6. Promote Peace: Encourage peace, justice, and harmony in all activities.

This has led to mixed reactions from netizens who have shared their thoughts in the comments section.

Facebook user Taufiq Razif disagreed with one of the guidelines, arguing that they should not treat the issue as solely humanitarian but also as a religious matter.

“I'm sorry. I'm afraid I have to disagree with these guidelines. Why should we view matters that are related to the faith of the Muslim community in a neutral manner?

“The issue of the occupation and colonisation of Masjid Al Aqsa is not solely a humanitarian issue. It is an issue related to our religion. We cannot remain neutral.

“Anyone who supports the Education Ministry in changing these guidelines, please respond a bit,” he said in the comment section.

Another user Muhaimin Safaruddin, expressed concerns that the guidelines seem overly cautious.

“I'm sorry, YB (Fadhlina), these guidelines seem to be overly considerate of non-believers and have left us, your fellow Muslims, feeling concerned,” he said.

Dim Kmehe, another user, questioned why these specific rules were outlined only for Palestine Solidarity Week.

“For activities unrelated to Palestinian solidarity, there should also be do's and don'ts. Some activities may not be suitable for students to be involved in.

“The guidelines are clear about all activities that should be carried out, and if they already exist, any school that violates them should be called in for an explanation,” they said.

Meanwhile, some netizens even raised the question "Who are you trying to please?" as this infographic has ignited controversy among Malaysians.