Pan Borneo issue: 'I am not accusing anyone, but PAC can obtain the documents' – Shafie Apdal

The Warisan president wants the PAC to investigate the appointment, ownership and payments involving the Sabah Pan Borneo Highway's former project delivery partner

ASYIKIN ASMIN
ASYIKIN ASMIN
16 Nov 2026 11:41am
Warisan president Datuk Seri Mohd Shafie Apdal has urged the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) to conduct a comprehensive investigation into the Sabah Pan Borneo Highway project, including the appointment and ownership of its former project delivery partner, stressing that he is not accusing any party of wrongdoing.
Warisan president Datuk Seri Mohd Shafie Apdal has urged the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) to conduct a comprehensive investigation into the Sabah Pan Borneo Highway project, including the appointment and ownership of its former project delivery partner, stressing that he is not accusing any party of wrongdoing.

 

KOTA KINABALU – Parti Warisan president Datuk Seri Mohd Shafie Apdal has called for a comprehensive investigation into the appointment of the Project Delivery Partner (PDP) for the Sabah Pan Borneo Highway project, stressing that he was not accusing any party of wrongdoing.

The former Sabah chief minister said the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) should examine how Borneo Highway PDP Sdn Bhd (BHPSB) was appointed in 2016, including who recommended the company and the criteria used in its selection.

"I am not accusing anyone of wrongdoing. However, the PAC has the authority to obtain documents that are not available to the public.

"I had already stated in January 2020 that politicians should not be involved in managing the PDP. My position on this remains unchanged," he said in a statement on Monday.

His remarks followed a statement by Domestic Trade and Cost of Living Minister and Papar MP Datuk Armizan Mohd Ali, who, together with six other Gabungan Rakyat Sabah (GRS) MPs, planned to submit a memorandum to the PAC seeking a wider investigation into the implementation of the Sabah Pan Borneo Highway project.

Mohd Shafie also urged the PAC to establish the actual ownership of BHPSB and determine whether any political leaders or public office holders had interests in the company.

He said the investigation should establish whether an open tender was conducted before BHPSB's appointment and identify its beneficial owners, directors and shareholders between 2016 and 2019, particularly whether any were political party leaders or public office holders.

He also supported Armizan's proposal to expand the PAC's investigation to cover the findings in Auditor-General's Report 2/2026 on the project's implementation.

According to Mohd Shafie, Armizan had called for the investigation to examine the reasons behind the PDP's termination and its implications, as well as to summon contractors affected by the decision.

"The people of Sabah want answers that address the issue in full, not just selected aspects," he said.

Mohd Shafie said the investigation should also scrutinise the Federal Cabinet's December 19, 2018 decision to terminate the PDP model, the RM700.99 million paid to the PDP and the RM155 million settlement following its termination.

He also cited findings from the 2019 Auditor-General's Report on the WP21 Lahad Datu Bypass, which found that all 10 bidders failed to meet at least one minimum qualification requirement, while the selected contractor had no experience in road construction.

He said the PAC should examine other work packages awarded by the PDP and review the contractors appointed under the arrangement.

"If there were issues with their appointments or performance, why were some of them retained or reappointed after the PDP was terminated? The PAC should look into these decisions and determine who was responsible," he said.

Mohd Shafie further called for scrutiny of the parties involved in the RM448.36 million paid in consultancy fees, the project's funding arrangements, 19 work packages that began before Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) approval was obtained and the loss of data involving 77,299 project files.

He also questioned whether any consultants or subcontractors who received part of the RM448.36 million in consultancy fees had links to BHPSB's directors or shareholders.

"The Sarawak Pan Borneo Highway was largely funded through DanaInfra. Was the same financing approach ever considered for Sabah?" he asked.

Meanwhile, Mohd Shafie urged the PAC to investigate the differences in land acquisition compensation between the Sabah and Sarawak Pan Borneo Highway projects.

According to the respective Auditor-General's Reports, land acquisition compensation for the Sabah project amounted to RM1.447 billion, compared with RM700 million for Sarawak, despite the two projects involving nearly similar land areas.

He said the figures indicated that compensation in Sabah ranged from approximately RM545,000 to RM647,000 per hectare, compared with about RM287,000 per hectare in Sarawak.

"That is almost twice as much. A difference of this scale needs to be explained.

"The PAC should also identify the largest compensation recipients and the landowners, including whether any land was purchased after the route alignment was announced or whether there were links to interested parties. This should be examined through the proper PAC procedures," he said.

 

 

Download Sinar Daily application.Click Here!

More Like This