Student crime: Is mental illness a factor?

Various factors could influence a school student's involvement in crime, including peer influence and their level of cognitive maturity.

21 Nov 2026 11:00am
Photo for illustration purposes only.
Photo for illustration purposes only.

KUALA LUMPUR - Criminal acts involving school students are becoming increasingly worrying.

Such incidents are no longer confined to places outside school premises. In recent times, cases of physical assaults, including attacks involving sharp weapons against fellow students and even teachers, have been reported within school grounds - institutions that are supposed to provide a safe environment for children to learn and build their future.

The growing number of such incidents has sparked public concern and fuelled debate over the effectiveness of the country's education system. However, some have also attributed these acts of violence among children to mental illness.

But is that really the case?

Not every student has a mental disorder

Commenting on the issue, Universiti Malaysia Sabah Faculty of Psychology and Social Work senior counselling lecturer Dr Tuan Norbalkish Tuan Abdullah said it would be unfair to label every student involved in criminal acts as someone with a mental health problem.

She said various factors could influence a school student's involvement in crime, including peer influence and their level of cognitive maturity.

"Crime is not a diagnosis. Some students become involved in criminal behaviour not because they have mental health problems, but rather due to peer pressure, opportunities to commit offences or impulsive decision-making," she told Bernama.

Tuan Norbalkish said society should also not dismiss the possibility that some students involved in criminal acts might be facing more complex issues, including undiagnosed Conduct Disorder, Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) or substance abuse.

Therefore, she said, these students should undergo comprehensive assessments by qualified professionals to identify the psychological, emotional and behavioural factors that may have influenced their actions.

"With proper assessment, appropriate intervention and support, they can not only be helped to change but also given an opportunity to rebuild their lives in a more positive direction," she said.

Early warning signs

Elaborating further, Tuan Norbalkish said early indicators that could help identify students at risk of engaging in criminal behaviour included significant changes in their emotions and behaviour.

She said such changes could be identified by comparing their current state with their previous attitudes and personalities.

"Emotionally, warning signs that warrant attention include becoming easily angered or agitated, increasingly withdrawing from others, losing interest in their surroundings and showing a decline in empathy, such as displaying little concern for or laughing at the suffering of others.

"Behavioural changes that could serve as early warning signs include frequent truancy, a sudden decline in academic performance, taking up smoking or vaping, involvement in substance abuse, as well as carrying sharp objects without informing others of their intended purpose," she said.

However, she stressed that the presence of any one of these signs did not necessarily mean that a student was at risk of becoming involved in crime, as emotional and behavioural changes were also part of adolescent development.

Nevertheless, if several indicators appeared simultaneously and persisted over time, the situation warranted serious attention from parents and schools.

She also said society should understand that the adolescent brain was still developing, particularly the parts responsible for judgement, decision-making and impulse control.

This could make teenagers more likely to react emotionally before having the chance to consider the consequences of their actions.

The situation becomes more challenging, she said, when students have never been exposed to the skills needed to identify, understand and put a name to the emotions they are experiencing.

She said adolescents in such circumstances might realise they were experiencing unpleasant emotions but be unsure whether these stemmed from sadness, shame, disappointment, fear or other feelings.

"When these different emotions become mixed up without being properly understood and managed, anger often becomes the easiest reaction to express. This is also influenced by various environmental pressures, including family conflicts, examinations and financial problems.

"An adolescent who lacks the skills to manage stress and, at the same time, has no trusted adult to turn to for support or to share their feelings with, risks allowing pent-up stress to accumulate and eventually manifest itself through negative emotional and behavioural changes," Tuan Norbalkish added.

Emotional neglect from childhood

Asked whether emotional neglect could be among the factors contributing to students' tendency to engage in crime, she agreed that it could have a significant influence on an individual's behavioural development.

She said studies on Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) had consistently shown a link between traumatic experiences in early life and the tendency to engage in risky behaviours, including criminal activities, later in adulthood.

According to her, emotional neglect was often overlooked because a child's physical needs had been adequately met.

"Some children have enough food, own mobile phones and receive pocket money, but no one asks whether they are really doing okay or how they are feeling emotionally each day.

"On the surface, they appear to be adequately cared for, but in reality, they grow up suppressing their feelings and dealing with their emotional struggles alone," she said.

Tuan Norbalkish added that her experience conducting counselling sessions at a rehabilitation centre had exposed her to various accounts of clients who had grown up in troubled family environments.

Among the recurring experiences were parental divorce marked by conflict and hostility, domestic violence and parental involvement in drug abuse.

Acknowledging that such experiences and family backgrounds were not an excuse to justify criminal behaviour, she said understanding the root causes and traumatic experiences individuals had endured since childhood was crucial if society wanted to address the problem comprehensively and break the cycle of criminal involvement.

"This is not about justifying crime. But if we want to break this cycle, we need to understand where those wounds began.

"...and when children feel unappreciated at home or in school, they will seek out groups that are willing to accept them, even if those groups are the wrong ones (and do not comprise good individuals). For these children, whoever offers them protection and a place to belong will be regarded as family," she said.

Look beyond the criminal act

Sharing a similar view, registered counsellor Faizah Mohamed Othman said efforts to address students' involvement in crime should not focus solely on the offences committed.

Instead, she said, such efforts must also take into account the students' life backgrounds.

"As a counsellor, I believe our focus should not simply be on asking 'what has this student done wrong', but also on what is happening in their lives and what interventions are needed.

"We need to understand the underlying causes without condoning acts that harm others. Mental health problems should not be used as a label to explain every criminal case involving students," she said.

Elaborating further, Faizah said School Guidance and Counselling Teachers (GBK) played an important role in detecting early warning signs of risk, providing interventions, coordinating referral processes and acting as a link between students, families, teachers and healthcare services.

She said their role was not to predict which students might become criminals, but rather to identify the underlying factors affecting their well-being.

Among the measures that could be implemented were building trust-based relationships with students, conducting appropriate interviews and screening sessions, assessing safety risks where threats were identified, and planning interventions in collaboration with the school.

"Information from discipline teachers, class teachers and parents is also important in helping us understand the students' backgrounds and behavioural changes.

"However, all such information must be handled in accordance with confidentiality principles and shared only with relevant parties on a need-to-know basis," she said.

All parties must work together

Faizah said that in cases involving serious threats, possession of weapons, plans to harm others or repeated acts of violence, counsellors needed to work with the school's crisis management team and the authorities, where necessary.

Apart from providing guidance and individual and group counselling sessions, GBK teachers were also responsible for planning and implementing various prevention and rehabilitation programmes to help students develop their capabilities and achieve physical, mental, emotional and social well-being.

Meanwhile, rehabilitation programmes should also be emphasised, with a focus on helping students develop healthier coping skills in dealing with stress, depression and declining mental well-being.

"Among the initiatives that can be implemented are support programmes to help students manage emotional stress, smoking and vaping cessation clinics, as well as consultation sessions with parents of students identified as potentially having specific learning needs, such as ADHD, dyslexia and autism.

"In addition, GBK teachers also play a role in coordinating referrals to appropriate healthcare facilities, with the involvement and cooperation of parents or guardians, to enable students to undergo examinations, professional assessments and further interventions according to their individual needs," she said. - BERNAMA

Download Sinar Daily application.Click Here!

More Like This