Three state election defeats a serious warning for PH - Analyst
The coalition must focus on restoring public confidence by addressing the cost of living, increasing incomes and creating quality employment opportunities.

PUTRAJAYA – Pakatan Harapan's (PH) underwhelming performance in three state elections serves as a serious warning to the coalition ahead of the next 16th General Election (GE16), particularly over the risk of losing more marginal seats in mixed and Malay-majority constituencies.
Political analyst Dr Mohammad Tawfik Yaakub said the election results in Johor, Negeri Sembilan and Melaka showed that PH faces significant challenges in retaining support among Malay voters, youths and fence-sitters.
He said the results also indicated that PH's position as the leading coalition in the Federal Government does not necessarily translate into an advantage in state elections.
Instead, voters are increasingly assessing the government's performance based on its ability to address the cost of living, economic well-being, administrative effectiveness and the extent to which political promises are translated into tangible benefits for the people.
"PH must view the results of these three state elections as a warning pattern, rather than merely isolated defeats.
"If this trend continues, PH risks losing more marginal seats in GE16, particularly in mixed and Malay-majority constituencies," he said.
The 16th Melaka state election on Saturday saw BN retain control after winning 21 of the 28 State Legislative Assembly seats, while PH, through its component party DAP, secured four seats, with PN winning the remaining three.
The results also saw the BN-PN alliance command 24 seats, giving it a two-thirds majority in the Melaka State Legislative Assembly.
Elaborating on PH's performance, Tawfik said the coalition won only eight of the 56 seats in Johor, 11 of the 36 seats in Negeri Sembilan and four of the 28 seats in Melaka.
More concerning, he said, was that all four PH seats in Melaka were won by DAP, while PKR and Amanah failed to secure any seats.
The situation highlights the challenges PH needs to address, particularly in strengthening support for its component parties ahead of GE16, which could take place in 2027.
Meanwhile, Tawfik said PH should take seriously the possibility of losing support among traditional voters if the declining trend continues.
He said the coalition must focus on restoring public confidence by addressing the cost of living, increasing incomes and creating quality employment opportunities.
"PH must also overhaul its political strategies and election machinery, particularly after the results of the three state elections showed that its existing approach has been less effective," he said.
He added that efforts to strengthen support among Malay voters and young people must involve a more grassroots-oriented approach, rather than relying solely on reform narratives and the government's achievements.
"PH must also ensure that the government's policies and economic achievements are genuinely felt by the people in their daily lives to restore voter confidence ahead of GE16," he said.
Tawfik predicted that calls for GE16 to be held earlier would grow stronger following BN and PN's victory in Melaka.
"BN and PN may want GE16 to be brought forward, while PH has a political interest in extending its term in government to restore public support," he said.
However, he said Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim need not bow to such pressure as long as he retains majority support in the Dewan Rakyat.
"I expect PH to be more inclined to hold GE16 towards the end of 2027 rather than early that year, to give the coalition room to carry out its political recovery process," he said.
Download Sinar Daily application.Click Here!

