Internal PKR debate: Zero gain, ill-suited for now - Analysts

SHAH ALAM - The ongoing debate between PKR deputy president candidates Datuk Seri Rafizi Ramli and Nurul Izzah Anwar has been deemed untimely given the current political environment, which calls for a more cautious approach.

Political analyst Professor Dr Ahmad Fauzi Abdul Hamid stated that the debate would not benefit PKR, which is currently working to regain support, particularly among Malay voters.

“While Rafizi has the upper hand when it comes to facts and data, debating doesn’t align with the traditional values of the Malay community.

“If Rafizi wins the debate, is that really what PKR needs at this point?," he asked.

He further pointed out that PKR is not the dominant party in government, and such debates could harm its image, especially among Malay voters, who would likely focus on the confrontation rather than the content of the debate.

Fauzi also stated that the public often doesn’t base their opinions on intellectual arguments or facts, but instead reacts more to clashes between Malay leaders within the same party.

He stressed that debate culture is not widely supported or celebrated within Malay society, even from a religious perspective.

He praised Nurul Izzah for turning down Rafizi’s debate invitation, describing it as a wise decision that could help PKR in its efforts to win over Malay hearts.

“In this context, Nurul Izzah made the right choice by opting out. Although Rafizi has the facts and figures on his side, he must recognise that this approach is not the priority right now,” he said.

Meanwhile, Universiti Utara Malaysia (UUM) political analyst Muhammad Afifi Abdul Razak pointed out that the appropriateness of the debate depends on several factors, including its format, context and timing.

“If the debate is structured properly, professionally facilitated and focused on policy issues rather than personal attacks, it could be beneficial. However, given the tension within the party, the timing might be off and it could escalate the situation.

“In short, whether the debate is appropriate depends on its objectives and whether it can be conducted constructively to support the party’s democratic process,” he added.

Afifi also cautioned that the debate could deepen divisions within PKR by creating the perception of factions or opposing camps, which political opponents could exploit to portray the party as unstable or divided.